People
The New Party News

News from the New Party

Friday, June 08, 2007

Totalitarian environmentalism

President Vaclav Klaus of the Czech Republic has made the following comments in front of an American Congressional committee:
What I am really concerned about is the way the environmental topics have been misused by certain political pressure groups to attack fundamental principles underlying free society. It becomes evident that while discussing climate we are not witnessing a clash of views about the environment but a clash of views about human freedom.

As someone who lived under communism for most of my life I feel obliged to say that the biggest threat to freedom, democracy, the market economy and prosperity at the beginning of the 21st century is not communism or its various softer variants. Communism was replaced by the threat of ambitious environmentalism. This ideology preaches earth and nature and under the slogans of their protection – similarly to the old Marxists – wants to replace the free and spontaneous evolution of mankind by a sort of central (now global) planning of the whole world.

The environmentalists consider their ideas and arguments to be an undisputable truth and use sophisticated methods of media manipulation and PR campaigns to exert pressure on policymakers to achieve their goals. Their argumentation is based on the spreading of fear and panic by declaring the future of the world to be under serious threat. In such an atmosphere they continue pushing policymakers to adopt illiberal measures, impose arbitrary limits, regulations, prohibitions, and restrictions on everyday human activities and make people subject to omnipotent bureaucratic decision-making. To use the words of Friedrich Hayek, they try to stop free, spontaneous human action and replace it by their own, very doubtful human design...

The policymakers are pushed to follow this media-driven hysteria based on speculative and hard evidence lacking theories, and to adopt enormously costly programs which would waste scarce resources in order to stop the probably unstoppable climate changes, caused not by human behavior but by various exogenous and endogenous natural processes (such as fluctuating solar activity).

This neatly encapsulates the fears that the climate change lobby is driving a totalitarian agenda, largely independent of any scientific evidence or justification.  Indeed much of this agenda has been in place since long before the climate change panic ensued.  There is indeed cause for concern that the politics may be driving the science, rather than the other way round.  The current mania for recycling, in the evident absence of an adequate infrastructure to process the vast amounts of material now being collected, is a case in point.  Increasing controls are being imposed on people's behaviour in order to implement policies which at best, have not been thought through, and at worst restrict freedom unnecessarily and arbitrarily to placate the whims of an unaccountable post-democratic bureaucracy.  This relatively trivial example will be dwarfed by future impositions on travel and economic activity, if current trends continue.  Our freedoms are at serious risk.  If this is the way to save the world, what kind of world will we have saved?

[Thanks to Melanie Phillips]